A Dubai content creator’s experience highlights the legal risks of posting negative reviews and speaking out online.

Dubai: Dubai-based content creator Noor Ul Ain did not anticipate a legal warning when she posted an Instagram story about a drink that left her feeling jittery.
She had regularly ordered food from a restaurant that offered a complimentary drink with every purchase. While she had no particular issue with the product, she did not enjoy how it made her feel and shared on Instagram that she would prefer to give it to a delivery rider.
What she viewed as a simple expression of personal preference soon led to a message from the business, asking her to take down the story or risk legal action for defamation.
Rather than escalate the matter, Noor chose to delete the post.
“This experience has changed how I feel about sharing honest opinions and feedback online. I simply shared that a drink didn’t suit me personally. I didn’t criticise the brand or tell anyone not to buy it, so receiving a message warning me of legal action was a real shock,” she told Gulf News.
“My concern is that if even a mild, personal opinion can lead to legal action, people will simply stop sharing their honest experiences online – which their audience deserves to hear.”
She believes that sharing authentic experiences is essential to maintaining trust with her audience. However, the incident has also highlighted the need for greater clarity among consumers and reviewers about where personal opinions end and defamation begins.
When can a negative review amount to defamation?
According to Ludmila Yamalova, Founder and Managing Partner of HPL Yamalova & Plewka FZCO, the UAE does not impose a blanket ban on negative online reviews. Consumers are entitled to share their dissatisfaction with products and services, but the language they use and the circumstances surrounding their comments are important.
“The specific wording and context matter. Not everything said in a review is legally protected, particularly where the review could unfairly damage someone’s reputation,” Yamalova said.
Yamalova explained that the key distinction is between sharing a personal experience and making allegations that could harm an individual’s or business’s reputation.
“The risk increases with offensive language, personal attacks, accusations of dishonesty, or serious allegations. Context also matters, including whether comments reflect genuine feedback or an attempt to publicly shame or damage a business’s reputation.”
The UAE does not have a blanket ban on negative reviews. Consumers are free to share their experiences and express dissatisfaction with products or services. However, the wording and context of a review are important. Not every statement is legally protected, particularly if it could unfairly harm someone’s reputation.
Ludmila Yamalova, Founder and Managing Partner of HPL Yamalova & Plewka FZCO Legal Consultancy
Ludmila Yamalova
Founder and Managing Partner of HPL Yamalova & Plewka FZCO
Under Article 43 of Federal Decree-Law No. 34 of 2021 on Countering Rumours and Cybercrimes, online insults and defamatory statements can carry imprisonment and/or fines ranging from Dh250,000 to Dh500,000.
However, this does not mean that every negative review amounts to a criminal offence.
Ahmed Elnaggar, CEO of Elnaggar & Partners, said criticism can become legally problematic when it moves beyond expressing dissatisfaction and includes insults or allegations that could damage someone’s reputation.
“The law does not prevent consumers from sharing negative feedback. What matters more is the nature of the language used, rather than whether the comments portray the business positively or negatively,” he said.
There is an important distinction between saying ‘I’m not satisfied with this business’ and making more serious allegations about its conduct. A statement is not automatically protected simply because it contains no obvious falsehoods or offensive language.
Ahmed Elnaggar, CEO of Elnaggar & Partners
Ahmed Elnaggar
CEO of Elnaggar & Partners
Can a business take legal action over a personal opinion?
Yamalova said the likelihood of a complaint progressing against someone who simply describes how a drink made them feel would generally be low. Such a comment, she explained, is not inherently insulting or defamatory. The situation is different when someone uses offensive language or makes serious allegations against a restaurant, its owners or employees.
She also highlighted the difference between receiving a legal threat and successfully pursuing a criminal complaint.
“In the UAE, criminal defamation complaints generally begin with the police, who assess whether there are grounds to refer the matter to Public Prosecution. Prosecutors then decide whether to pursue criminal charges before the courts. So, there are several stages of scrutiny before a complaint reaches a judge.”
A business is entitled to take steps to protect its reputation, but receiving a legal warning does not, by itself, establish that a consumer has committed an offence.
Even if the police summon someone over a complaint, this does not necessarily mean charges will follow. Authorities may simply be examining the allegations and could ultimately decide to close the case.
Yamalova added that police may also help resolve such disputes by facilitating an agreement in which a consumer removes the disputed comments and the complainant withdraws the complaint.
Does telling the truth protect you from defamation claims?
According to Elnaggar, UAE defamation law does not follow a straightforward rule that a statement is legally safe simply because it is true. At the same time, truthful criticism is not automatically unlawful.
“There’s a real gap between saying ‘I’m not satisfied with this business’ and claiming something more serious about the business’s behaviour. Just because a statement doesn’t contain obvious falsehoods or offensive words doesn’t automatically absolve you from any legal punishment,” he said.
He explained that whether a statement amounts to defamation or an insult depends on whether the relevant legal requirements are met. This makes the wording, context and overall meaning of an online post particularly important.
How one UAE food reviewer handles negative experiences
For food reviewers, whose work revolves around sharing opinions about restaurants, maintaining audience trust while staying within legal boundaries can require a different approach.
Hani AlMalki, who runs the Instagram account @bedouinfoodie, has chosen to publicly feature restaurants and dishes he recommends while addressing disappointing experiences privately.

“I made a conscious decision when I started my food blog not to publish negative restaurant reviews. Instead, I defined the purpose of my account as ‘identifying and documenting excellence’. I wanted my followers to feel confident that if they saw a restaurant or dish featured on my account, it was because I genuinely believed it was good and worth experiencing.”
Hani’s approach has been shaped partly by discussions with his friend, prominent UAE lawyer and fellow restaurant enthusiast Dr Habib Al Mulla. Their conversations have explored the difference between expressing a personal opinion and using language that could potentially create legal complications.
“For example, saying ‘I didn’t like this restaurant’ or ‘I didn’t enjoy this particular dish’ is an expression of personal opinion. But saying something like ‘the food tasted expired’ or ‘the food belongs in the garbage’ can be much more problematic. The former could imply a food safety issue, while the latter could be considered insulting. The choice of words matters enormously,” he explained.
Rather than avoid criticism altogether, Hani chooses to share his concerns directly with restaurant owners and chefs.
“When I have a disappointing experience, I generally prepare a detailed feedback report and send it privately to the chef or restaurant owners. I’m often quite direct in my criticism, but my intention is to help them improve rather than publicly damage their reputation,” he said.
“My philosophy is simple – I’m not here to tell people where not to eat. I’m here to tell them where they should eat.”
Honest feedback does not automatically amount to a legal offence
Lawyers stress that consumers are generally free to share negative experiences publicly, provided their comments do not cross legal boundaries.
The key distinction lies between expressing dissatisfaction and making statements that could be considered insulting or defamatory. Whether a particular review breaches the law depends on its wording, context and overall meaning.
“Ultimately, consumers should not feel they must remain silent about negative experiences. But how they express their opinions can make all the difference legally,” Yamalova said.


